voted orlando's best NY-Style slices

HANDMADE BROOKLYN PIZZA & ITALIAN DINNERS

NY-Style & Brick oven pies

Entrees, pastas, & heros

appetizers & fresh salads

handmade desserts

catering for events

fresh pizza by the slice

Over 26 different types, Only available in-store

Got Questions? Contact Us ⟶

Sal's Pizza Bar

4.6

Based on 1116 reviews

review us on

Oliver Foley

3 weeks ago

This place has pretty authentic New York style pizza. There’s not a lot of pizza shops around Orlando like this that are actually good. I got the cheese and margarita. I love that the cheese is thin, white, just like in New York. The actual sliced tasted great, the interior of the place is cool. They got an oven and you can see how they make it, service was nice, but mine was long

Francisco Cordero

3 weeks ago

Brianna Van Kirk

4 weeks ago

Outstanding experience from start to finish. The service was genuinely exceptional. Every single person I interacted with was kind, welcoming, and seemed to truly care. What stood out most was that even as employees were leaving for the night, they all told us goodbye and thanked us on their way to their cars. That level of kindness is rare and speaks volumes about the people here.
A special shoutout to Sal, front-of-house Sal with glasses—who was absolutely fantastic. He went above and beyond and made the experience even better. I also have to mention the young boy who insisted on carrying my food out for me, even though I told him not to worry. His enthusiasm and eagerness to help was genuinely heartwarming.
And of course, the pizza was delicious. Great food is one thing, but when it's paired with this level of hospitality, it turns a meal into a memorable experience. I'll definitely be back.

waterboy01440

4 weeks ago

Steven Persaud

1 month ago

Sal and Jay made this visit exceptionally well. I was borned and raised in New York, and I immediately felt at home when I walked in. Thank you for the great food, but more importantly, thank you for making me feel like family. Till the next time guys…

Bojan Parlov

4 months ago

Wow, when it comes to Pizza, Sal’s your spot. Cannot get enough of this place. Their pasta, is just pure joy. Throw some garlic knots into the mix and your tummy will love you forever. Definitely my favorite pizza spot in town.

Update: Doctor told me that my cholesterol was high and need to cut out white starch. Well, first thing before I tackle this, is a good meal from Sal’s. No regrets.

Anaiss Madera

4 months ago

Sal’s Pizza absolutely exceeded my expectations. The food was fantastic—everything tasted fresh and well made. The wings had amazing flavor, and the garlic knots were truly out of this world (honestly some of the best I’ve ever had). The guest raved about it.

What really set Sal’s apart, though, was the team. They helped me pull together an event we’re responsive to all my questions and requests. Their professionalism, flexibility, and willingness to help made the entire process stress-free.

I’m so grateful for their support and delicious food. Highly recommend Sal’s Pizza for both everyday meals and special events—you won’t be disappointed!

Kimberly Gonzalez

4 months ago

First time eating here with my family of 7 and we were all blown away with the fresh & buttery garlic knots lightly topped with cheese and parsley for such a great price. We also ordered the meatball + ricotta which unfortunately only consisted of two meatballs & one scoop of ricotta cheese ( do not recommend if sharing with multiple people) , the flavor was simple yet still delicious & fresh. I had the gluten free personal pepperoni pizza and I would rate it an 8. The rest of the party had an 18” half cheese + half pepperoni pizza which was also fresh and looked lovely. The food took about 20 minutes and the customer service was great.

Kyle Kuchta

5 months ago

Lived in DP all my life and have never had pizza like this. Maybe carerras or carinos from about 25 years ago. Got the vodka burrata smaller coal fire pie and a larger NY style cheese. Both thin and crispy, the way it should be. Good undercarraige no flop. The sauce is what really triggers my NY pizza memories . It is truly on point. Perfect spice to sweetness ratio. Love these guys definitely will be back. Many times

andres cuevas

6 months ago

Sal’s Pizza Bar absolutely delivers that real-deal New York pizza. Thin, crispy foldable slices with the perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and crust — the kind of pizza that reminds you why NYC pizza has the crown. Every bite was on point.

Now let’s talk about the garlic knots… BUSSIN. Soft, buttery, garlicky, and seasoned just right. I could’ve eaten the whole basket and still wanted more.

The cannoli (yeah, I cleaned the plate) was the perfect finish — crisp shell, creamy filling, not too sweet, just straight up satisfying.

On top of all that, they’ve got a solid beer selection that pairs perfectly with the pizza. Cold beers, good vibes, and quality food all around.

If you’re craving legit New York–style pizza with great sides and beer to match, Sal’s Pizza Bar is the move. Definitely coming back. 🍺🔥

come in, stay awhile and refresh

Stay and enjoy your food while it’s hot and fresh! Our pizzeria offers plenty of indoor and outdoor seating. We also have a bar serving a variety of wines and beers on tap.

want to keep up with everything sal's pizza bar

Join over 13k pizza lovers in enjoying new slice releases, epic collabs, behind-the-scenes, and live footage from our kitchen!

1,200+ Reviews

why is sal's pizza the best migliore mejor

At Sal’s we make everything from scratch. From our handmade sauce and dough to our locally sourced vegetables and meats, we take pride in every ingredient that goes into our food. We’re not your local chain, we’re Brooklyn’s favorite pizza brought to Florida – and you won’t find a more authentic NY-Style slice around.

(Did you know we’ve been featured on the news?)

voted orlando's best NY-Style slices

HANDMADE BROOKLYN PIZZA & ITALIAN DINNERS

NY-Style & Brick oven pies

Entrees, pastas, & heros

appetizers & fresh salads

handmade desserts

catering for events

fresh pizza by the slice

Over 26 different types, Only available in-store

come in, stay awhile and refresh

want to keep up with everything sal's pizza bar

1,200+ Reviews

why is sal's pizza the best migliore mejor

sitemap

order online

get in touch